I spotted this on Twitter/X and it reminded me of an old post, appropriate for Fridays during Lent
I have posted on this in the past, but repetita iuvant as we say in Latin.
ORIGINAL POST from long ago and far away….
Someone sent me a copy of a letter written by the Archbishop of New Orleans to a member of his flock about eating alligator during Lent. The answer is “yes”. You may eat alligator during Lent.
This is old news to readers of this blog, of course. Last year I posted this, a question in Latin from a reader about alligator, which ought to have settled the whole thing:
QUAERITUR: Abstinentia de carne lacertina aut crocodrillina
Ex lectoris e-pistulis extractum:
Reverendo patro Ioanni Zuhlsdorf discipulus C. salutem et commemorationem in precibus suis. Gratias meas, sivis, ob opum tuam tibi agere volo. [Acceptae.] Mihi, catholico iuveni et discipulo in collegio liberalum artis et liberalum (aut impudicarum) mentum, scripturae tuae magnam auxilium fuerunt. Mox Ludovicianam meabo. Quaeritur: Sineturne corpus alligatoris feria VI in Quadregesima sine violando abstinentiam Quadragesimae edere?
Corrigendis ignotis…
Ossificatus manualista impoenitens respondeo de paginis Compendii Theologiae Moralis (Sabetti-Barrett) n. 331, :
CLICK TO BUY
Nomine carnis veniunt omnia animalia in terra viventia ac respirantia, ut communiter admittunt theologi ex regula tradita a S. Thoma vel, ut S. Alphonsus innuit, n. 1011, animalia quae sanguinem habent calidum; vel illud quod consuetudo regionis ut carnem habet; vel, si nec consuetudo praesto sit, dubium solvi potest considerando mentem Ecclesiae in sanciendo delectu ciborum, ut comprimendae ac minuendae carnis concupiscentiae per salutarem abstinetiam consuleret; examinetur, an huiusmodi animal simile sit aut dissimile iis quorum esus interdictus est et an illius carnes humano corpori validius nutriendo et roborando idoneae dignoscantur; et si ita appareat, ista caro inter vetitas est ponenda. Benedict XIV., De syn. dioec., lib.11, c. 5, n. 12. Haec quatuor multum deservient omni dubitationi solvendae.
Ergo, crocodrilli et lacertae inter reptilia sunt et amphibia.
Edi ergo possunt feriis sextis et tempore Quadragesimae.
Omnibus tamen diebus ab eis edimur!
So, there you have it.
You can eat alligator and crocodile on Fridays of Lent.
ADDENDUM:
Speaking of fasting and abstinence, during Lent I get all sorts of questions about what can be eaten and how much of the what. Old manuals of moral theology help me out with most of the things people throw at me.
By the way, the justification for the eating of alligator was that they are cold-blooded. I think Benedict XIV was unaware of the existence of the endothermic (warm-blooded) Moonfish. But I digress…
Yes, you may fry your fish and chips in liquefied beef fat. We can also eat gelatin from meat but not peptonized beef. (I had to look that up.) I believe, according to local custom, in some parts of South America capybara is allowed.
NB: Muskrat can be eaten on Fridays in some parts of Michigan. I’m told it tastes of dirty dishrag and has the consistency of very old, thick asparagus.
Loading ...
Many years ago I was on a mission trip to Central America during Holy Week, and we were served chicken on Good Friday by the sponsoring local Catholic church. We were all Americans, and we didn’t eat the chicken. We were later scolded by the priest for being uncharitable and insulting the local parishioners who cooked and served the food. We were also told that in Spanish speaking countries chicken (pollo) is not meat (carne), and therefore allowed on Good Friday. Plus poor people are exempt from the no meat rule anyway.
I don’t know if any of that’s true or not, as I never researched it, but it popped into my mind reading this post. I guess I can see the charitable part, but the distinction between chicken and beef escapes me.
Eating alligator, muskrat, capybara or moonfish would always be penance for me.
I recall frog legs being acceptable too (sorry Kermit). A fish place in my area serves frog legs and alligator nuggets. They are both tasty. Fried okra is pretty good too.
Or, as Joe Swift would put it:
Take a big hunk of gator,
Slap it on a big piece of bread.
Salt will make it greater.
Go ahead, go ahead, take a big bite Fred.
Alligator meat . . . . is really all reet.
Now that song will be stuck in my head for a week.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=drxNlnAaJJ4
But since chicken technically are dinosaurs, I think that by extension, we should be able to eat that too.
@poohbear
When I left Protestantism and joined a schismatic traditional Catholic group run by Benedictines, we learned they did not eat quadrupeds, i.e., beef or pork, etc.
However, if someone gave them a beef pot pie (or served them one if eating at their home), then they would eat it out of respect. They said this applied also to Fridays as they followed (and recommended, but did not require) traditional fasting and abstinence rules.
Be that as it may, the priest had a duty to warn you IMHO.
Your picture seems to indicate that it is also not a sin for an alligator to eat a Catholic on Fridays during lent.